How to Choose TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats, Catnip (Chicken, Catnip & Cheddar Flavour), 454g Tub: Complete 2026 Buyer's Guide

Why Cat Treats Matter More Than You Think

Cat treats aren’t just a token of affection—they’re a practical tool for behaviour training, stress reduction, and supplementing your cat’s diet. The wrong choice can upset a sensitive stomach or contribute to weight gain, while an informed pick improves your bond and your cat’s quality of life. I’ve lived through trial-and-error with my own pair—one gorges on anything, the other turns tail at artificial scents. What you pick for treats truly impacts their happiness, waistline, and even trust during grooming or vet visits. That’s why choosing the right cat treats is more important than flashy packaging lets on.

Key Criteria When Comparing Cat Treats

Ingredient Transparency and Quality

Start by examining the ingredient list. Cats are obligate carnivores: protein—especially animal-based—should dominate. Treats based on fillers like corn, wheat, or high sugar content are red flags, especially for indoor or senior cats at risk of obesity. Authority sources like the American Association of Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) [1] recommend choosing products where protein is the first ingredient and artificial colours are limited.

With TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats, Catnip (Chicken, Catnip & Cheddar Flavour), the focus does fall on appetizing flavours, but you must check for real meat content and avoid overusing as a food substitute. The tub holds 454g, so rationing is key.

Texture and Palatability

The texture of cat treats directly influences acceptance. Creamy treats, like these TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups, win over even finicky cats—particularly seniors or those with dental issues. The product’s “texture fondante” (creamy, melt-in-mouth) means you can serve directly for licking or layer onto kibble to boost meal appeal. In my home, this helped entice a previously suspicious rescue to finally try her dry food.

Caloric Content and Portion Control

Overfeeding treats quickly sabotages weight management. Obesity is the number one health issue I see among indoor cats, confirmed by The British Veterinary Association [2]. TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats are “faible en calories” (low-calorie), so you can use daily within sensible limits. Always check the kcal per treat and compare it to your cat’s daily allowance. The tub format tempts you to ‘just one more’, but discipline is crucial.

Packaging and Storage

The big 454g tub is handy—it keeps treats fresh and reduces waste. If you have multiple cats, or treat often, a large tub prevents frequent re-buying. The secure lid also keeps curious paws out, something you’ll value if you’ve ever found treats scattered on the floor at 2am.

Flavour Variety for Picky Cats

Variety matters, especially with mood swings or multi-cat households. This TEMPTATIONS pack mixes chicken, catnip, and cheddar flavours—covering both savoury and herbal profiles. Some cats crave one note, others get bored. In my experience, changing flavours only matters if you introduce them gradually; don’t overwhelm your cat’s senses.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid When Buying Cat Treats

Assuming All “Cat Treats” Are Healthy

Not all cat treats are created equal, and many brands make impressive claims without real substance. I’ve seen treats labeled “healthy” that list sugar and artificial flavourings in their top ingredients. Regardless of branding, always investigate the fine print.

Overfeeding Due to Misleading Serving Suggestions

Large tubs like the 454g format can encourage overuse. Ignore enticing photos—stick to precise daily portions, typically not exceeding 10% of daily calorie intake. Even low-calorie snacks like TEMPTATIONS can tip the scale if given indiscriminately. Use a measuring spoon if necessary.

Ignoring Individual Sensitivities

Cats vary in dietary needs. Older cats, those prone to urinary troubles, or animals on strict diets should not be given treats liberally. Introducing a new treat? Start with one, and observe for vomiting or changes in stool. If your cat is on prescription food, get your vet’s advice, or check resources like our renal cat food guide.

Disregarding Storage and Freshness

Keep your tub sealed in a dry, cool place. Exposure to air can turn creamy treats stale quickly, making them unappetizing even for enthusiastic eaters. This is especially true for treats with a higher moisture content or dairy elements like cheddar.

Using Treats to Replace Meals

It’s tempting to reward often—but treats complement, not replace, balanced meals. This should be obvious, but I’ve heard from more than one stressed owner who “just gives treats”—leading to nutritional imbalance.

Best Cat Treats Picks by Budget and Use Case (2026)

For Budget-Conscious Owners

You need value without sacrificing palatability or nutrition. TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats offer a cost-effective bulk tub that lasts for weeks even with regular use. If your main goal is simple, crowd-pleasing treats (especially for training), this tub is a smart bet.

If your cat has special needs—like gluten intolerance—consider investing a little more in grain-free or single-protein treats. Those come at a premium, but avoid digestive upsets for sensitive cats.

For Multi-Cat Households

The 454g tub splits easily among several cats. Adventurous eaters can each enjoy a flavour, and the soft, creamy texture adapts for kittens, adults, and seniors. Portion into smaller containers to ration and avoid staleness—especially if you’ve got treat-thieves like mine.

For Training and Enrichment

Creamy, high-palatability treats are perfect for clicker training, recall, or distraction during stressful events (travel, nail trim). TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups stick to a low-calorie formula, so you can repeat rewards without guilt. For cats requiring extra motivation, blending different flavours keeps interest high.

Premium Choices for Fussy or Senior Cats

If your cat turns her nose up at dry or crunchy textures, look for soft, lickable treats like TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups. Creaminess helps cats with missing teeth or reduced appetite. For true premium quality, look at brands offering 100% meat or single-ingredient chews—but be ready to pay double or more.

Comparison Table: TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups vs. Alternatives

• $$: Around $12-18 CAD (bulk, mid-range)
• $$$: $18+ CAD (premium, small packs)

Your Cat Treats Questions Answered

What are the ingredients in TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats?

Official ingredients focus on chicken, catnip, and cheddar flavours, with a creamy texture designed to appeal to even the pickiest cats. Always double-check for protein sources and exclude treats with lots of fillers or artificial additives if possible.

Are TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats safe for daily use?

Yes, when fed within the recommended portion, these cat treats fit into a daily feeding routine. They are low in calories, but avoid letting treats exceed 10% of your cat’s energy intake.

Do TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups help with training cats?

Absolutely. Their creamy texture and strong aroma work well for positive reinforcement during training, nail trims, or vet visits. Their palatability makes them ideal for teaching new behaviours.

How should I store TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats?

Use the original tub, keeping it tightly sealed. Store in a cool, dry place—avoid the fridge (moisture) and keep away from direct sunlight to prevent spoilage.

Can kittens eat TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats?

Yes, the soft, creamy formula is gentle enough for kittens (usually above 8 weeks old). Break treats into smaller pieces if needed, and introduce new foods slowly.

Are these treats suitable for cats with food allergies?

Check each flavour’s ingredient list; while the three-flavour mix covers broad palates, some cats may react to dairy or specific proteins. If your cat has known allergies, consult your veterinarian before use.

Are TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups grain-free?

The official description doesn’t specify grain-free status. If your cat is grain-intolerant, consult your vet or choose treats labelled “grain-free,” like those discussed in our grain-free cat kibble guide.

How many treats should I give per day?

Generally, limit treats to under 10% of daily caloric intake. For these TEMPTATIONS, that typically means 5-10 treats daily for an average adult cat. Adjust for weight, age, and activity.

Do these treats help with dental health?

Creamy, soft treats like these won’t reduce tartar. For oral care, choose crunchy dental treats or consult our senior cat food guide.

What should I do if my cat refuses TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups?

Don’t force treats. Mix a small amount in with your cat’s normal food, or try another flavour later. Cats can be cautious with new items, so patience or offering alternatives is key.

Our verdict — TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats, Catnip 454g Tub

What struck me on day one with the TEMPTATIONS Mix-Ups Cat Treats, Catnip (Chicken, Catnip & Cheddar Flavour), 454g Tub was the irresistible smell and creamy texture—my shy tabby, who avoids crunchy snacks, immediately licked a small portion off my finger. The multi-flavour mix genuinely keeps things interesting: my food-driven Bengal is crazy for cheddar, while the tabby prefers the chicken and catnip blend. I did find the tub’s easy-open lid prevents staleness, but be prepared—the large container makes it all too tempting to over-treat.

This tub is ideal for multi-cat homes, picky eaters, and older cats who struggle with harder treats. It isn’t the best choice for cats with dairy or protein allergies—owners should always check the ingredient list first. Budget-wise, the bulk size offers solid value, but be strict about rationing to keep your cat trim. If your priority is pure simplicity or single-ingredient nutrition, a premium freeze-dried option outperforms, but at double the cost and half the convenience. As an everyday, crowd-pleasing reward, this is a reliable pick—and, in my experience, well worth the mid-range price tag when you need something irresistible that cats look forward to.